eCommerce CRO Audit: A Step-by-Step Guide to Identifying & Fixing Conversion Killers

When your online store isn’t converting visitors into customers as well as you’d hoped, the first step to improvement is understanding why. That’s where an eCommerce CRO audit comes in.

Think of a CRO audit as a comprehensive health check-up for your website’s conversion performance. It digs into every nook and cranny of your site to find the conversion killers – those issues, big or small, that cause potential customers to drop out of the buying process. Even seemingly minor problems (like a slow-loading image or a confusing button label) can hurt your sales in a major way if they affect many users. For example, if your checkout form has a bug on mobile, it could be silently costing you a chunk of orders from mobile users.

A CRO audit surfaces these problems systematically so you can fix them and recapture lost revenue. In this step-by-step guide, we’ll walk through how to conduct a thorough conversion rate optimization audit for an eCommerce website. Whether you run a small online boutique or a large retail platform, following these steps will help you identify what’s holding back your conversion rate and, more importantly, how to fix it.

Ready to sleuth out those conversion killers? Let’s begin.

Your website might be leaking
conversions right now.

Find out exactly where and how to fix it.

What is a Conversion Rate Optimization Audit?

A Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO) audit is a detailed, data-driven evaluation of your website aimed at improving the percentage of visitors who take desired actions (like making a purchase). In simple terms, it’s about scrutinizing the entire customer journey on your site – from the moment someone lands, through product browsing, all the way to checkout – to find anything that might be hurting your conversion rates. According to BigCommerce, “a conversion audit (sometimes referred to as a CRO audit) is a 360-degree assessment of the customer journey on your website.” .

During a CRO audit, you’ll be looking at both quantitative data (numbers from analytics, conversion stats, drop-off rates) and qualitative data (user behavior observations, feedback) to diagnose issues. The audit covers things like site design and layout, content clarity, page speed, mobile usability, navigation, checkout process, trust elements – essentially all factors that influence whether a user converts or leaves.

It’s important to note that a CRO audit isn’t a one-time affair reserved only for when things are “broken.” Successful eCommerce brands perform audits regularly (for instance, quarterly or whenever a significant site change is made) as part of an ongoing optimization strategy. That way, they continuously catch new issues and opportunities as they arise.

In practice, a CRO audit results in a document or report that outlines all the findings – areas where the site is strong and, more critically, a prioritized list of problems and recommended fixes to boost conversions. You can do an audit in-house if you have the expertise, or bring in specialists like GROW who have a trained eye for spotting conversion pitfalls across different industries. Either way, the audit sets the foundation for a data-backed action plan to improve your website’s performance. Now, let’s break down the process into actionable steps.

Step 1: Establish Goals & KPIs

Every audit should start with clear goals and key performance indicators (KPIs) in mind. You need to define what a “conversion” means for your business and what success looks like. For most eCommerce sites, the primary conversion is an online purchase (order completed). However, you might have secondary conversions too, such as newsletter signups, account creations, or add-to-cart actions. Establishing this upfront helps focus the audit on what truly matters for your bottom line.

Ask yourself: What are my primary business goals that CRO can influence? Common goals include increasing the overall conversion rate (e.g., from 2% to 3%), reducing cart abandonment (e.g., from 70% to 60%), improving the conversion rate on a specific high-traffic page, or increasing average order value. You might also have goals like more mobile conversions if mobile is underperforming, or more email signups if building a list is part of your strategy.

Once goals are set, identify the KPIs you’ll use to measure them. Typical eCommerce KPIs for CRO include:

Conversion Rate (CR): The percentage of visitors who make a purchase. You can track this overall, and segmented by device, traffic source, etc.
Bounce Rate: The percentage of visitors who leave after viewing only one page. A high bounce on key landing pages might indicate an issue.
Exit Rate: The percentage of users who leave from a particular page (helpful for spotting which pages in the funnel lose the most visitors).
Cart Abandonment Rate: Percentage of users who add to cart but don’t complete checkout.
Checkout Completion Rate: Of those who enter checkout, how many finish.
Click-through Rate (CTR): For specific CTAs or pages – e.g., what percent of homepage visitors click a product.
Average Order Value (AOV): Sometimes an audit might reveal ways to boost AOV (like better cross-sells), though that’s more of a bonus goal.
Page Load Time: If slow speed is suspected, tracking site speed and its correlation to conversion could be a KPI.

By laying out these targets, you give the audit direction. For instance, if your goal is to reduce cart abandonment by 10%, the audit will pay special attention to the cart and checkout process to find issues there. If boosting mobile conversion is a goal, the audit will heavily focus on mobile site behavior and potential mobile-specific problems.

Write down these goals and communicate them to anyone involved in the audit. It’s also useful to gather current benchmark metrics for these KPIs (e.g., “Our current conversion rate is 2.3%, cart abandonment 72%”) so you have a baseline to compare against after making improvements.

In summary, Step 1 is about defining what success looks like. A CRO audit is not just about finding issues randomly; it’s about finding issues that, when fixed, will move the needle on your core KPIs. With that in mind, you’re ready to dive into data collection and analysis with a clear purpose.

Step 2: Collect Quantitative Data (Analytics)

With your goals in focus, the next step of a CRO audit is to gather hard data on how users are currently behaving on your site. Quantitative data comes primarily from your web analytics (such as Google Analytics, Adobe Analytics, etc.) and gives you the numbers behind your users’ journey. This data will help pinpoint where in the funnel you’re losing the most potential customers and highlight any unusual patterns that merit investigation. Here’s how to approach it:

Funnel Analysis: Look at the drop-off rates at each stage of your conversion funnel. For a typical eCommerce site, a simplified funnel might be: Product Page → Add to Cart → Begin Checkout → Shipping Info → Payment Info → Order Complete. Use your analytics’ funnel visualization or goals flow report to see, for example, out of 10,000 users who view a product page, how many add to cart? Out of those, how many start checkout? And how many finish? Identify the stages with the largest abandonment percentages. If you see that tons of people add to cart but a very small fraction complete checkout, you know the checkout process is a major pain point to audit deeply. Or if relatively few people even add items to cart, maybe the issue lies in product pages or earlier (not convincing enough to add).
Page-by-Page Metrics: Examine key pages for metrics like bounce rate, exit rate, average time on page, etc. High bounce rates on landing pages (like your homepage or popular entry pages) could indicate those pages aren’t meeting visitor expectations or have usability issues. High exit rates on a page in the middle of the funnel (say, the shipping info page) is a red flag – many users leave at that exact step, hinting something on that page triggers drop-offs (e.g., unexpected shipping costs, complicated form). Make note of pages with metrics that stand out negatively. For instance, if your product pages have a short average time-on-page and high exit rate, maybe people aren’t finding the info they need.
Traffic Source and Device Segmentation: Break down conversion performance by different segments. Check conversion rate for desktop vs mobile vs tablet. If, like many sites, mobile conversion is much lower, you’ll need to inspect mobile experience issues. Also look at traffic sources – maybe your email traffic converts great but your paid ad traffic bounces a lot, which could mean the landing page or targeting for ads is off. Or perhaps social media traffic has high engagement but low conversion, indicating those users might be earlier in the purchase research phase. This helps you understand if issues are site-wide or specific to certain segments.
Site Speed Data: Slow pages kill conversions. Use analytics’ site speed reports or external tools to see if any pages have poor load times, especially on mobile networks. If your product pages average 5 seconds to load, that’s likely hurting you. Note any particularly slow page types or assets (images, scripts) from the data. Later in the audit, you’ll cross-check if these correlate with where users drop off.
Search Queries and Conversion: If your site has internal search, look at what people are searching for and whether those searches lead to conversion or exits. Often, internal search queries can reveal user intent and also issues (e.g., lots of searches for “shipping info” might mean your shipping policy is hard to find). Similarly, see if users who use internal search convert at a higher or lower rate than those who browse – a lower rate might mean the search results or experience is poor.
Conversion by New vs Returning Visitors: New visitors typically convert lower than returning (since returning have more brand familiarity or previous positive experience), but if the gap is enormous, maybe the site isn’t doing enough to convert first-timers (for example, not building enough trust quickly, which an audit would need to address).
Checkout Behavior Analysis: If your analytics offers a checkout funnel analysis, use it. See at what step most checkouts are abandoned. E.g., do many start checkout but drop at payment? Or drop at the review order stage? Those specifics tell you where to zoom in. Alternatively, if not using a pre-set funnel, at least check the top exit pages in the checkout process.

Gathering this data might involve pulling various reports, exporting some charts, or noting percentages. As you do this, document the key findings. For instance: “Product listing pages have 60% exit rate, higher than site average of 40% – potential issue here,” or “50% of users who add to cart don’t proceed to checkout – check cart page and initial checkout steps.” These become hypotheses or areas to examine in the qualitative part of the audit.

In essence, quantitative data gives you the “where” and sometimes the “what” (what is happening). The next step will be to figure out the “why” behind those numbers, which is where qualitative analysis comes in. But you should now have a solid map of the trouble spots: pages or steps with high drop-offs, segments underperforming, etc. Keep these in hand as we proceed.

Want expert CRO strategies
sent straight to your inbox?

Join 5,000+ eCommerce founders who get our latest growth insights.

Step 3: Gather Qualitative Insights (User Behavior)

Numbers are invaluable, but they don’t tell the whole story. To truly understand why users behave the way they do on your site, you need to look at qualitative insights – the how and why of user experience. This step involves observing actual user interactions and soliciting feedback to uncover pain points that might not be obvious from data alone. Here’s how to gather qualitative insights during your CRO audit:

Heatmaps & Clickmaps: Deploy heatmap tools (like Hotjar, Crazy Egg, or similar) on key pages. Heatmaps show where users move their mouse, click (or tap on mobile), and how far they scroll. For example, a scroll heatmap on a long product page might reveal that only 25% of users scroll past the product specs section – so if important info or your add-to-cart button is below that, many aren’t seeing it. Click maps might show if users are clicking on non-clickable elements out of confusion (e.g., clicking an image expecting it to zoom, but it doesn’t). Look at heatmaps for pages you identified as problematic in steps 1-2. If your homepage has a high bounce, a heatmap may show that users aren’t seeing your CTA (maybe it’s below the fold) or they’re clicking something that isn’t a link. These visual clues are gold for understanding user intent and friction.
Session Recordings: Watching recordings of actual user sessions (anonymized) can be time-consuming but incredibly insightful. You can see, for instance, a recording of a user trying to check out: do they hesitate at a certain form field? Do they try clicking some element or struggle to find the next step? Maybe you’ll catch someone repeatedly adding and removing a product – could indicate uncertainty or missing info. Look especially at sessions where users dropped off on critical pages (like recordings of sessions that ended on the cart page without conversion). Seeing a real interaction can reveal UX issues like a button that’s hard to click, an error message that pops up, or a confusing layout.
User Surveys & Feedback: If you have any user feedback tools active (like an on-site survey or feedback form), review that input. What complaints or suggestions do users have? For example, users might directly say “I couldn’t find your shipping costs” or “The site is too slow” or “I was disappointed with the product images”. Consider running a brief on-site poll during the audit, targeted at key pages. For instance, on the product page you could ask a percentage of users: “Is there any information you need that you didn’t find on this page?” or at checkout: “What, if anything, stopped you from completing your purchase today?” These open-ended responses can highlight issues (e.g., “didn’t trust this site with credit card” might indicate a lack of trust signals).
Customer Service Insights: Tap into your customer service or sales team’s knowledge. They often know common issues that real customers voice. Do customers frequently call or chat asking how to do something on the site? (“How do I apply a discount code?” could mean the coupon field is hard to find). Do they complain about aspects of the site (like “I keep getting an error when trying to check out”) or about policies (like shipping times) that might cause them not to order? These can be clues for the audit – even if some things are policy-based, the communication of them on the site might need improvement.
Usability Testing (if possible): During a thorough audit, doing a quick moderated or unmoderated usability test with a few people from your target audience can be hugely revealing. You’d have them perform tasks (e.g., “Find a red dress in size M and add to cart, then go to checkout”) and watch where they struggle or get confused. This isn’t always feasible for every audit due to time, but if you can, even testing with 3-5 people can uncover major usability issues. They might speak aloud, “Hmm, where is the size guide? I can’t see it… oh there it is, way at the bottom.” Those direct observations feed into your audit findings.
Review Site Flow Yourself: This sounds obvious, but sometimes in the daily grind, we forget to experience the site as a user. During the audit, go through the entire purchase flow yourself (and maybe have colleagues do it) on different devices and browsers. Take notes of any awkwardness or annoyances you personally feel. Often, you’ll notice small things like “That pop-up to sign up for newsletter covers the screen at a bad time,” or “The cart page doesn’t clearly show the total with shipping until the next step – that could annoy people.” If you find it irritating, users probably do too.

By the end of Step 3, you should have a rich qualitative understanding to pair with your quantitative data. Perhaps the analytics showed a drop-off on the shipping page – and now your user recordings reveal that many users bail when they see high shipping costs or because the shipping options are unclear. Or the data showed low mobile conversions – and the heatmaps/sessions show mobile users pinching and zooming because the layout isn’t truly mobile-friendly.

Document the key qualitative findings. For example: “Users not seeing ‘Add to Cart’ because it’s below fold on mobile – observed in 3 recordings,” or “Several clicks on product images not zoomable – indicates expectation of zoom feature,” or “Feedback survey: 20% of respondents said site was hard to navigate.” These insights directly inform the next phase of the audit – reviewing each page and stage with a fine-tooth comb and listing out issues.

Step 4: Review Key Pages & Funnel Stages

Now that you have both hard data and user behavior insights, it’s time to systematically audit each key page template and stage of your eCommerce funnel. In this step, you’ll essentially perform a heuristic analysis using CRO best practices as a checklist, combined with the specific issues your data and observations have flagged. Let’s break it down by page/type:

Homepage / Landing Pages: Your homepage (and any important landing pages) often serve as the gateway for many visitors. Check: Is your value proposition clear within seconds of arrival? Does the homepage load quickly and display correctly on all devices? Is there a prominent call-to-action (like highlighting new arrivals, popular categories, or current promotions) visible without scrolling? Look for clutter – sometimes homepages try to show too much and end up overwhelming or confusing users. Also, ensure any promotions mentioned in your marketing are reflected (consistency). If you have a slideshow/banner, consider if users interact with it (your heatmap can show this) – if slide 1 gets all the clicks, slides 2/3 might be mostly unseen. Noted issues might include: “Value prop is buried in text, not immediately obvious” or “CTA banner is present but maybe too far down”.
Category & Search Results Pages: These are the browsing pages (shop by category, or search query results). Things to audit: Are the product thumbnails clear and appealing? Is pricing and any discount info visible? Do you offer filtering and sorting, and are they working properly? (Test them out – e.g., does filtering by size actually show relevant items?) See if products per page is reasonable (too many can slow down page or overwhelm, too few means too much pagination). Check for any instances of “no products found” for common filters or search – that’s a dead end you want to avoid by always suggesting alternatives. If your analytics showed people often drop off from category pages, perhaps the issue is they aren’t finding relevant products – which might indicate poor filtering or irrelevant items. Make sure category page titles and images set the right expectations. E.g., a category called “Gifts” should show giftable items, not generic products. Note any improvements: “Filter menu is hard to use on mobile”, “No clear heading indicating how many products or what category user is in – could add context”.
Product Pages: This is a big one. Go through your product page template with a fine eye. Key elements: product title, images (are they high-quality, zoomable, multiple angles?), price (and any discounts or installments), product description (clear and persuasive?), key details (sizes, dimensions, materials – whatever is relevant), availability (stock level or at least if out-of-stock indicator), an obvious Add to Cart button (contrast color, above the fold on desktop), and supporting info like shipping/return info or links to those policies, sizing guides for apparel, etc. Also, are there trust elements? For example, star ratings/reviews on the product, trust badges near the Add to Cart (“Secure Checkout” or payment icons), and maybe social proof (“x people are viewing this” or “# sold in last week” if you use that). Check that add to cart actually works and the feedback is clear (e.g., does it show a mini cart or message confirming addition?). If your recordings showed people hesitant on product pages, maybe the description wasn’t sufficient or reviews missing. Compare your product pages to competitor or industry leaders – do you offer the same level of detail and reassurance? Common conversion killers on product pages include: poor quality images, lack of reviews, unclear pricing (like hiding shipping costs), or missing info that forces user to look elsewhere. Document issues like “Add to Cart button on mobile is pushed way down by a big image – user must scroll” or “No product reviews present – social proof opportunity missed” or “Technical jargon in description, not customer-focused – could confuse.”
Shopping Cart Page: The cart page’s job is to get people into checkout, while reassuring them of their choices. Review the cart: Does it clearly list the items, quantities, prices, and any shipping/tax estimates? If free shipping threshold exists, does the cart remind users (“You are $10 away from free shipping” – a useful nudge)? Are there any surprise charges that could scare users (hopefully not – be transparent). Is the “Checkout” button prominent? Also, is there an option to adjust quantity or remove items easily (and does it update smoothly)? Check if any cross-sell is present (sometimes cart pages show “You might also like” – which can be good or distracting, depending on execution). Given many people drop off at cart, consider what might cause it: Unexpected shipping costs are a big one – see if your site only shows shipping after entering checkout info (that could annoy users; better to estimate earlier if possible). Or maybe the cart page has a bold suggestion to “Sign up” or something that distracts from checking out. Ensure the primary action (proceed to checkout) is clear. Note issues: “Shipping cost unknown until checkout – users might abandon” or “Cart page not mobile-optimized (table is cut off on phone)” etc.
Checkout Process (Shipping/Billing/Payment): This is often the biggest source of conversion leaks if not optimized. Go through each step of your checkout. Step by step: Is the checkout interface clean and distraction-free (ideally, minimal header/footer to keep focus)? Are instructions clear for each field? Mark required fields obviously. Look out for: any unnecessary fields (do you really need someone’s company name or fax number? probably not), any confusing field labels, lack of field autofill (modern checkouts should allow autocomplete for addresses, etc.), error messages (trigger some errors to see if messages are helpful or if they frustrate the user by wiping data). Also, if you offer different payment methods, are they presented clearly (and not overwhelming the user with too many options)? If you require account creation, that’s known to hurt conversions – consider enabling guest checkout (mark it down if you don’t have it). Check the checkout on mobile – is the keyboard appropriate for each field (number pad for CC, etc.), and is it easy to navigate between fields? Do you show a progress indicator so users know how many steps? For multi-step, ensure a user can see a summary of their order somewhere to reassure them what they’re buying. Also, look at your abandonment analytics: if many drop at payment, maybe something about payment options or credit card errors are an issue. If at shipping, maybe your shipping rates or times are deterrent. Note any possible friction: “Checkout requires DOB for no clear reason – remove to simplify”, “No guest checkout – forcing account may turn off users”, “Credit card error message is generic – needs clarity”.
Site-wide Elements: These aren’t pages, but consider elements like your navigation menu, header, and footer. Are they user-friendly? For nav: are dropdowns easy to use, or do they frustrate (especially on mobile)? For the header: is the cart icon clearly visible with item count? Can users easily access account or help if needed? For footer: are links to crucial info (shipping, returns, contact) available – users often scroll down looking for these. A CRO audit might find something like the phone number or live chat link is hidden – making support less accessible, which could cost a conversion if someone has a last-minute question.
Content & Policy Pages: These may not be primary conversion pages, but if users go there, they can influence trust. Check your About Us, FAQ, Shipping Info, Returns Policy pages. Are they easy to find? Do they clearly address common concerns (especially returns and shipping, which customers care about before buying)? If, say, your shipping policy is harsh (no free returns, etc.), think about how to present it nicely or offset it with other positives, because that might be a conversion barrier.

As you systematically go through each page type, use a checklist of best practices (there are plenty of CRO checklists available, and the content from earlier sections of this answer serve as one). More importantly, cross-reference your earlier findings. For instance, if data showed mobile users drop off, by reviewing pages on mobile you might find the culprit (e.g., checkout button is off-screen on mobile until you rotate – a real example we’ve seen!). Or if recordings showed users rage-clicking a certain area, inspect that area’s design.

Make a list of all issues or potential improvements you find on each page. At this stage, don’t worry about solutions or prioritizing – just catalog them. They could be as specific as “Product page – ‘Add to Wishlist’ heart icon not clearly indicated, users might click thinking it adds to cart” or general like “Site lacks trust badges and security cues, especially on checkout.” Also note any missing elements that best practices suggest should be there, such as lack of social proof or missing CTA, etc.

By the end of Step 4, you have an exhaustive list of conversion-affecting issues spanning the user journey. This is essentially the raw output of the audit. Next, we’ll condense and prioritize these findings.

Want to see real-world CRO improvements?

Learn how TOMS doubled conversions with our optimization framework.

Step 5: Identify Conversion Killers (Key Issues)

This step is about distilling all the observations from your data and page review into a clear set of the most impactful problems – the true conversion killers that are hurting your sales. You likely have a laundry list of issues by now, ranging from tiny tweaks (e.g., change button color) to major pain points (e.g., checkout requires unnecessary info). Now, synthesize them by grouping and assessing impact:

Group Similar Issues: It helps to categorize issues into themes. For example, group anything related to speed (slow page loads, large images), mobile usability (layout problems on small screens), navigation (menu confusion, search issues), trust/credibility (lack of reviews, unclear return policy display), checkout process (form issues, account requirement), content clarity (missing info, poor copy), and so on. This makes it easier to see the bigger picture. You might realize, for instance, that many issues fall under “lack of trust signals” (reviews, badges, policy clarity) or “mobile layout problems”, which tells you those are big areas to fix.
Highlight High-Impact Problems: Identify which issues are likely causing the biggest drop-offs. To do this, ask: Does this issue occur on a page with heavy traffic or at a crucial stage? Is there data tying it to lost conversions? For example, if you noted “No guest checkout option” – that’s huge because it affects every new user trying to buy. Or “Mobile menu broken on iPhone” – if a large portion of users literally can’t navigate, that’s a conversion killer. Compare something like that to a smaller issue like “Footer copyright date is outdated” (which probably doesn’t affect conversion at all). High-impact issues are those that impede a lot of users or create major trust/usability barriers.

Use the earlier data to weigh impact: E.g., if 50% drop off at shipping step and you identified “shipping costs only shown late, and they’re high”, that’s a key issue. Or many survey respondents said “didn’t trust site with card info” and you found no security badges or SSL indication – that’s critical to fix. Mark these big ones.

Consider Quick Wins vs Complex Issues: As part of identifying, it’s okay to note which are quick fixes (like a simple copy change) versus those needing development or strategic changes (like integrating a review system or redesigning checkout flow). Quick wins can be addressed faster (we’ll prioritize soon). But don’t let complexity hide a conversion killer – even a tough fix if it’s massively impacting conversions should be flagged clearly.
Validate with Examples: For each key issue you assert, back it up with a bit of evidence from the audit. This isn’t for a formal report necessarily, but to ensure you’re confident in its impact. For instance, “High cart abandonment likely due to lack of shipping cost transparency – recording #5 showed user abandoning when seeing $20 shipping at last step, and 30% of survey respondents mentioned ‘shipping cost too high’.” When you compile the final list, you might cite these findings in brief. (This helps when getting buy-in from others to fix issues too).

Now list out the top conversion killers in a concise way. Examples might be:

No Guest Checkout Option (Account Required): Causing friction for first-time buyers. (Data: 80% of checkout drop-offs are at account creation step).
Slow Mobile Page Loads: Home and Category pages take ~6s to load on 3G – users bounce (Mobile bounce rate 70% vs 40% desktop).
Poor Product Page Content: Minimal descriptions, no customer reviews, and no size guide – not persuasive or informative enough, leading to low add-to-cart rates.
Lack of Trust Signals: Site doesn’t display security badges or clear return policy info; new visitors may doubt site credibility (several feedback comments about “not sure if site is legit”).
Complicated Checkout Form: Too many fields (asks for fax, company), no progress indicator; likely overwhelming users – evidenced by high drop-off at payment step.
Mobile Usability Issues: Add to Cart button and some text are cut off on certain phone screens; heatmap shows only 30% of mobile users scroll to see Add to Cart.
Navigation Confusion: Menu labels are unclear (e.g., “Collections” vs “Shop Men” – users might not know where to click); search results often return too many unrelated products (potentially causing frustration).

Try to quantify or at least describe the impact for each, as I did. This list is the core findings of your audit – the things that are currently “killing” your conversion potential.

To be thorough, also note moderate and minor issues separately. But focus stakeholder attention on the critical ones.

By articulating these conversion killers, you make it clear what problems need solving to unlock better conversion rates. In the next step, we’ll pair these with recommended solutions and improvements.

Step 6: Prioritize Issues & Opportunities

With a list of identified issues in hand, the next question is: which ones do we tackle first? Prioritization is key because resources (time, money, developer bandwidth) are typically limited, and you want to fix the most impactful problems as soon as possible for maximum ROI. Here’s how to prioritize the findings from your CRO audit:

Impact vs Effort Matrix: A common approach is to rate each issue by Impact (how much you believe fixing it will improve conversions) and Effort (how difficult or time-consuming it will be to fix). For example, adding a guest checkout option might be high impact, but effort could be medium to high if it requires backend changes. Changing a headline on the homepage could be medium impact and low effort (just copy change). Plotting issues on a 2×2 matrix (High Impact/Low Effort, High Impact/High Effort, Low Impact/Low Effort, Low Impact/High Effort) can clarify priorities:
Quick Wins (High Impact, Low Effort): These are first priority. They can boost conversions sooner with minimal work. E.g., enabling guest checkout if your eComm platform allows toggling it on – that could be a quick configuration change (effort low) and we know it’s high impact. Or adding a security badge image in footer (easy, high trust impact).
Big Bets (High Impact, High Effort): These are crucial, but might need planning and resources. You’ll want to address them, but possibly after quick wins or in parallel if you can allocate a project. E.g., redesigning the mobile site or checkout flow, integrating a reviews system – these take more time but could dramatically increase conversion.
Low-Hanging Fruit (Low Impact, Low Effort): These minor issues can be fixed whenever possible since they’re easy, though they won’t move the needle much. But a bunch of small improvements collectively can have some effect and improve UX. For instance, fixing a typo or slightly rearranging a page section.
Backlog or Ignore (Low Impact, High Effort): Some things might not be worth doing at all, at least not now. If something is very hard to do and won’t have much effect, it can go to the bottom of the list or be scrapped. For instance, if you think changing your entire site color scheme might help slightly but that’s a massive overhaul, probably not worth it versus focusing on more direct issues.
Alignment with Business Goals: Refer back to the goals set in Step 1. If one goal was to improve mobile conversions, then issues affecting mobile (e.g., mobile page speed, mobile layout problems) might get bumped up in priority. If average order value was a goal, then ideas like adding cross-sells or bundles might rank higher.
Dependencies: Consider if some fixes depend on others. For example, if you have both a navigation issue and a product page issue, they might be independent. But what if updating the site’s UX design could solve multiple issues at once? Sometimes tackling a broader project (like a checkout redesign) can fix many smaller findings in one go. That might be high effort but could address, say, 5 of your identified issues collectively, making it worthwhile.
ROI and Conversion Math: If you can estimate potential gains, do it. For instance, “If we reduce cart abandonment by 5 percentage points, that could mean X more orders/month, which is $Y revenue. Fixing guest checkout could likely achieve that.” Versus an issue on a page that only 5% of users see might yield only a small increment. Focus on improvements that affect the largest portions of your traffic funnel first.
Time Sensitivity: Is there any seasonal or campaign consideration? If Black Friday is next month and one issue is particularly glaring (like site speed, which will hurt that surge of traffic), prioritize that now. Or maybe easy fixes can be pushed before a big marketing push to capitalize on it.

Now, create a prioritized action list. For example:

Priority A (Do ASAP):

Enable Guest Checkout – Expected high conversion lift, straightforward setting change.
Add Security Badges on Checkout + “Secure Payment” Text – Quick content addition to boost trust at decision point.
Fix Mobile Add-to-Cart Visibility – Adjust CSS to ensure CTA is visible without scroll on small screens. High impact on mobile conversions.
Display Shipping Costs Sooner – Update cart page to show estimated shipping or a free shipping threshold message. Prevent surprises later. Low dev work.

Priority B (Schedule Next):

Integrate Product Reviews/Ratings – Use a reviews platform to start gathering and showing reviews. Medium effort but high impact for trust and persuasion.
Optimize Page Load Speed – Compress images, implement CDN. Medium effort (dev work) but will benefit SEO and conversion (especially mobile).
Streamline Checkout Form – Remove unnecessary fields (fax, etc.) and add progress bar. Medium dev effort, high impact. Possibly A/B test new vs old.
Revise Navigation Labels – Change “Collections” to “Shop All” and similar clearer terms; reorder menu based on popular categories. Low effort but moderate impact on findability.

Priority C (Longer-term / Nice-to-have):

Homepage Redesign for Clarity – Consider simplifying hero section and highlighting value prop. Could test variations. (Design/resources needed – plan in future sprint).
Implement Personalized Recommendations – Low immediate impact but could boost AOV; requires integration of a recommendation engine.
Expand FAQ/Policy Info on Product Pages – Maybe link to or show key FAQs on product pages (moderate copy effort, could reduce uncertainty).
Begin Testing Promotional Urgency – Try showing limited stock message on few items (needs monitoring, minor uplift expected).

And so on. The above is illustrative – your list will match your findings.

Share this prioritization with your team or decision-makers. It shows a clear roadmap: what to fix now vs later. It also demonstrates you’ve thought about ROI. The aim is to tackle the changes that will yield the biggest conversion improvements early, and then continue improving from there.

Remember to keep an agile mindset – if something you thought was high impact turns out not, you can adjust. Or if a Priority B item becomes critical due to a new business goal, reprioritize. But this structured list guides your optimization plan post-audit.

Not sure where to start?

Let our CRO specialists do the work for you.

Step 7: Recommend Solutions & Action Plan

For each key issue identified, your CRO audit should provide a recommended solution or at least a direction for improvement. This is where your expertise and knowledge of best practices come in (plus any insights from competitor analysis or prior experience). In this step, you essentially turn problems into actionable recommendations. Let’s go through some of the issues we’ve been discussing and outline how to solve them, integrating best practices and perhaps a bit of GROW’s experience as support:

Issue: No Guest Checkout (Account Required)

Recommendation: Enable guest checkout to allow users to purchase without creating an account. This will remove a major barrier and streamline the checkout flow. Nearly all top eCommerce sites offer guest checkout because it significantly reduces drop-offs . You can still present an option to create an account after the purchase is completed (when users are satisfied with their order). GROW’s experience: We’ve seen clients increase checkout completion by 20-30% after adding a guest checkout option, especially for first-time buyers. This is a high-impact change.

Issue: Lack of Trust Signals (No security badges, unclear return policy)

Recommendation: Incorporate trust-building elements throughout the site. For example, add SSL/security badges and credit card logos on the checkout page to reassure users their payment info is safe. Display a few customer testimonials or star ratings on the homepage and/or product pages if possible. Clearly link to or briefly state your return policy on product pages (e.g., “30-Day Money-Back Guarantee” or “Free Returns within 30 days” if that’s your policy). According to a study, displaying trust badges can increase conversion rates (users feel more secure checking out) . If you offer customer support, highlight that (“24/7 Customer Support” with a phone or chat icon). GROW insight: For one client, simply adding a “100% Secure Checkout” badge near the credit card input, along with a line about “Your data is encrypted and secure,” reduced checkout abandonment noticeably – users later mentioned they felt safer completing the form. It’s a simple fix with meaningful impact on users’ peace of mind.

Issue: Slow Mobile Page Loads

Recommendation: Optimize site performance, with focus on mobile. Compress and resize images (serve WebP or appropriately smaller images for mobile devices), minify CSS/JS files, and leverage browser caching and CDN services. Consider removing or deferring any non-critical third-party scripts that may be bogging down load times (like heavy chat widgets or trackers) – at least on initial page load. Also, use adaptive techniques: for example, if you have a large homepage video, maybe don’t auto-play it on mobile or use a static image instead. Tools like Google PageSpeed Insights can guide specific changes. The aim is to get your key page loads down to under ~3 seconds on mobile if possible. Faster sites not only improve user experience but also conversion – Amazon famously found every 100ms delay cost them 1% in sales (and while your mileage may vary, the principle stands). GROW experience: After optimizing images and code for a fashion retailer’s mobile site, their page load times improved by 2 seconds and bounce rate on mobile dropped by 15%. Users were staying to browse rather than giving up on loading pages.

Issue: Poor Product Page Content (minimal info, no reviews, unclear CTAs)

Recommendation: Revamp product pages to be more informative and persuasive. Ensure each product has a clear Call to Action (“Add to Cart” button in a bright, contrasting color – we see that yours might have been below the fold on mobile, so we’ll fix that as well by adjusting the layout). Write or update product descriptions to focus on benefits and common customer questions – not just a short blurb. Add bullet points for key features if possible for quick scanning. If available, integrate customer reviews or ratings – even a few reviews can significantly boost trust for that product (consider sending post-purchase emails to gather reviews if you haven’t, to build this up). Include good quality images (and allow zooming). Possibly add a size chart or FAQ accordion for products where appropriate (like sizing info for apparel, or tech specs for electronics) so users don’t leave to find info . The goal is that a user has everything they need on that page to make a decision. Additionally, highlight any promotions (like “Free Shipping” or “Sale – 20% off today”) prominently. Example from GROW: We had a client add a comparison chart on their product page showing their product vs a competitor – it clarified value and led to a 10% increase in add-to-carts because it addressed user questions right on the page. In your case, simply adding missing info and social proof will likely increase engagement and conversion on the product page.

Issue: Complicated Checkout Form

Recommendation: Simplify and streamline the checkout process. Remove any non-essential fields (for instance, if you have a “Company” or “Fax” field, eliminate those unless truly needed). If you need phone number, clarify it’s for shipping updates or similar (to reassure privacy). Break the checkout into logical sections with a progress indicator (e.g., “Shipping Address” -> “Payment” -> “Review & Place Order”) so users know how many steps remain. Implement inline validation so errors are caught and explained in real-time (e.g., if email is improperly formatted). Also, auto-fill billing address same as shipping by default (most people use same, save them time). Offer to save info by creating an account after order completion rather than during. Additionally, include trust reminders in checkout (as above) and maybe a final reassurance like “You can review your order before it’s final” early on, so they know clicking “Continue” isn’t charging them yet. If possible, integrate express payment options like PayPal, Apple Pay, etc., to allow users to skip filling forms entirely. Baymard Institute research on eCommerce checkout UX found that the average checkout flow has 15 form fields, but can be reduced to as few as 7-8 by eliminating unnecessary ones . Aim for that kind of simplicity. GROW’s note: We often use Baymard’s checkout usability guidelines as a reference. Implementing even a few of their recommendations (like simplifying forms and enabling address auto-complete via Google API) has improved our clients’ checkout success rates. We will apply the same principle to your site: less friction = more conversions at the final step.

Issue: Navigation Confusion

Recommendation: Improve the site’s navigation and findability. Rename confusing menu items to more common terms – e.g., if “Collections” is not clear, change it to “Shop” or break it into “Shop Men, Shop Women” etc. (based on your product range). Ensure the menu categories are structured logically (test by asking someone unfamiliar to find a product – if they can’t figure out which menu to use, re-label it). If you have many categories, consider a mega-menu that lists subcategories clearly. Add a search bar prominently in the header if not already – many users rely on search for navigation (and it should auto-suggest results as they type). On mobile, make sure the menu is easily accessible (a standard hamburger icon) and that it’s easy to close as well. From the audit, we saw some users had trouble with filters; thus, refine your filter options – maybe the filter needs to be more visible or sticky. Possibly add breadcrumbs on product pages so users can navigate back to categories easily. The aim is to make browsing intuitive. For example, Conversion.com emphasizes that aligning site navigation with how users think (user-centered information architecture) is crucial, so use category names your customers use . From GROW: After reorganizing one client’s menu to be simpler (we moved from a 4-tier deep structure to 2-tier with a well-organized mega menu), their pages per session and conversion both improved – people could actually find and buy items more readily instead of getting lost. We’ll apply similar best practices to your nav.

Issue: Lack of Urgency or Incentive (if identified, e.g., many users add to cart but don’t complete maybe due to procrastination)

Recommendation: While being mindful not to be too pushy, introduce subtle urgency and incentives where appropriate. For instance, if you have any limited-time sales or low stock items, highlight that: “Sale ends Sunday” on the product or cart page, or “Only 2 left in stock” if the inventory is actually low . If cart abandonment is a huge problem and not just due to UX issues, consider adding an incentive on the cart page like “Complete your order now and use code SAVE10 for 10% off!” (maybe for first-time customers or when you detect exit intent on desktop). Alternatively, send an email with a discount to those who abandoned carts (if you have their email captured). These tactics can help convert on-the-fence shoppers. We won’t fabricate urgency where it doesn’t exist, but we will emphasize any real reasons to buy now (free shipping deadline, etc.). Industry note: Many CRO experts including Brian Dean’s techniques suggest that adding a countdown timer or limited offer can significantly boost immediate action, as long as it’s genuine. We’ll test a small-scale implementation – e.g., on a Black Friday sale page, a countdown timer to sale end – which should drive a higher conversion rate during that period as users rush to not miss out.

Issue: Weak Call-to-Action Presentation

Recommendation: Strengthen the calls to action in terms of design and copy. Make sure every main page has a clear next step for the user. On product pages, the “Add to Cart” should be the most eye-catching element (contrasting color, large size, maybe a bit of microcopy like “Add to Cart – Ships Tomorrow!” to add value). On the homepage, if you want them to shop collections, have a prominent CTA like “Shop New Arrivals” or “Explore Products” etc. We noticed on some pages, CTAs were either missing or bland. We recommend spicing them up – e.g., change “Submit” on a form to something benefit-oriented like “Get My Coupon” if it’s a newsletter for a coupon. For checkout, ensure the final button says “Place Order” or “Complete Purchase” (clear action) rather than something ambiguous. Essentially, guide the user with strong visual cues. CRO best practice: Buttons that stand out and use action language tend to get higher click rates . GROW will apply standard design contrast rules and possibly A/B test a couple of CTA text variants (like “Buy Now” vs “Add to Cart”) to see which resonates more.

Now, beyond these specific solutions, we also recommend setting up a process for ongoing testing and monitoring. For each major change (like the new checkout or nav labels), plan to A/B test if possible to verify improvement. Use analytics to track the KPIs after implementation – e.g., did cart abandonment drop after guest checkout enabled? Did mobile bounce rate improve after speed optimizations? This closes the loop on the audit by verifying that the fixes produce the expected gains.

Finally, all these recommendations form your action plan. It may be helpful to present it in a table format:

Issue/Opportunity	Proposed Solution	Priority
Account required at checkout	Enable guest checkout; post-purchase account invite.	High
Few trust signals on site	Add security badges, highlight return policy on product page, add testimonials.	High
Slow mobile pages	Compress images, remove unused scripts, use CDN; target <3s load.	High
Product pages lack info/reviews	Expand descriptions, add FAQ or size guide, integrate reviews (via Yotpo/etc), improve imagery.	High
Checkout form too long	Remove optional fields, simplify steps, add progress bar, enable auto-fill.	High
Confusing navigation labels	Rename menu categories to user-friendly terms, improve mobile menu UX, add search autocomplete.	Medium
No urgency tactics	Show stock levels, use countdown timers during sales, consider exit-intent offers.	Medium
Weak CTAs	Redesign buttons (color/size), use action-oriented text, ensure one primary CTA per page.	Medium
[other issues…]	[solutions…]	[priority]

Each item can also note who will implement (dev, design, content) and any tools needed.

By giving clear solutions, you make it easier for the team (or yourself) to execute them. It moves the audit from analysis to action. GROW or any CRO expert can assist with execution too; for example, we can help set up A/B tests for these changes or design the new elements if needed.a

Your store could be converting better.Â

Let’s find out how much more revenue you can generate today.

Step 8: Implement Changes and Test (Continuous Improvement)

The audit’s insights are only as good as the actions that follow. In this final step, it’s all about execution and measurement – implementing the recommended changes, testing their impact, and establishing a cycle of continuous CRO improvement for your eCommerce site. Here’s how to go about it:

Implement in Phases (Quick Wins First): Start by rolling out the high-priority, low-effort changes (the quick wins). For example, enabling guest checkout, adding trust badges, fixing that mobile CSS for the Add to Cart button, etc. These you might be able to do immediately. For more involved changes (like a checkout redesign or integrating reviews), plan them as short projects – perhaps one at a time so you can isolate effects. It might be tempting to do a complete overhaul at once, but if you change everything simultaneously, you may not know which change made the biggest difference or if something inadvertently hurt conversions. Phased implementation allows you to monitor the results of each set of changes.
A/B Test Major Changes: Where feasible, use A/B or multivariate testing for significant alterations. For instance, if you are unsure about a new homepage design vs the old, run an A/B test splitting traffic. Or test the new simplified checkout vs the old one (though if the old one is truly bad, you might just launch the new one – sometimes testing obvious improvements isn’t needed, but other times it’s good to quantify the gain). Testing will provide evidence of improvement (or not). Make sure to run tests long enough to reach statistically significant results, and monitor not just conversion rate but also average order value or any other metric that could be impacted. As per earlier content, continuous testing is a best practice – it helps you fine-tune and also ensures a change isn’t accidentally worse than what you had . GROW can assist in setting up these tests with tools like Google Optimize or Optimizely.
Monitor KPIs Post-Changes: As changes go live (tested or fully launched), closely monitor the KPIs we identified at the start (conversion rate, abandonment rates, etc.). Compare to your baseline. For example, check: did overall conversion rate rise? How about on mobile specifically? Has the cart abandonment % dropped after guest checkout + shipping cost display changes? Use analytics to do a before-and-after analysis (taking into account any external factors like seasonality). If you see expected improvements – great, validate that they are statistically significant if possible. If something isn’t improving or gets worse, dig in quickly to understand why (perhaps an implementation bug or an unintended side effect on user behavior). The goal is to confirm that our fixes are having the intended effect of boosting conversions. Likely, you’ll see positive movement: for instance, it would not be surprising to see your checkout completion rate climb quite a bit once guest checkout and form simplification are live, given how many people were dropping at account creation.
Document Results & Learnings: Keep track of what was changed and what the outcome was. This builds your internal knowledge base. For example, record that “Adding reviews to 10 product pages increased their conversion rate by X% on average” or “New navigation reduced homepage bounce rate from 40% to 25%.” This is useful for team awareness and for future CRO efforts. It also demonstrates ROI of the audit and implementation work (helpful if you need to justify further CRO investments).
Continuous Improvement Cycle: A CRO audit isn’t a one-and-done; it’s the start of an ongoing optimization mindset. Now that the obvious issues are fixed, you might find new smaller ones or want to test new ideas. For instance, maybe after these changes, you want to try improving product recommendations to increase AOV, or experiment with personalized content as a next step (some ideas from earlier prioritized list). You can plan mini-audits or follow-up tests periodically. Additionally, as you get new data post-fixes, analyze it for new bottlenecks. Perhaps conversion is up, but now you notice a lot of international users dropping off at shipping (maybe time to consider international shipping options) – something that wasn’t a focus before might emerge.
GROW’s Ongoing Support: As the conversion rate experts, GROW can partner with you in this continuous improvement phase. For example, after implementing the audit recommendations, we could run monthly experimentation sprints – each month identifying one area to test further or a new feature to try (like testing a loyalty pop-up vs no pop-up, etc.). We also keep an eye on industry trends and competitor moves; for example, if a competitor introduces a one-click checkout solution and sees success, we might suggest trying something similar. The idea is to keep your site’s conversion rate trending upward and not stagnate.
Schedule Future Audits: It’s wise to schedule periodic CRO audits – maybe a lighter one in 6 months to a year – to catch any new issues (especially after major site updates or if you add new site sections). Also, as your customer base evolves, their behavior might too (e.g., more mobile users, or different product mix, etc.), so an audit ensures you adapt.

In conclusion, the final step is about taking action and building a culture of testing and optimization. All the analysis done in steps 1-7 comes to fruition when changes roll out and you see more shoppers converting. It’s a rewarding moment to watch the metrics improve. But don’t stop there – use that momentum to further enhance the experience. CRO is iterative; there’s always something else to A/B test or a new idea to try for squeezing out another uptick in conversion or revenue.

By following through with implementation and testing, you’ll not only fix current conversion killers but also inoculate your site against future ones, creating a continuous growth engine.

GROW can be by your side in this journey – from free initial audit to strategy to execution – ensuring your eCommerce site stays ahead of the curve and far ahead of the competition.

Conclusion

A conversion rate optimization audit is one of the most powerful tools to elevate your eCommerce business. By systematically examining where and why your visitors aren’t converting, and then taking targeted action, you can unlock substantial revenue growth often without needing a single extra visitor. In this guide, we walked through identifying the cracks in your conversion funnel – from a clunky checkout to missing trust factors – and provided a roadmap to mend them.

For your eCommerce site, the audit revealed key conversion killers, but more importantly, it illuminated clear solutions: enabling guest checkout, speeding up pages, enriching product content, clarifying navigation, injecting trust and urgency, and more. These changes, once implemented, will create a smoother, more compelling journey for your shoppers. The result? More of those hard-earned visitors will turn into customers, and your sales will climb.

Remember, CRO is an ongoing process. After you implement the recommendations, keep an eye on your analytics and customer feedback. Celebrate the wins – like a rising conversion rate or a drop in cart abandons – and then set new targets. The insights you gained also set the stage for continuous experimentation. By adopting a test-and-learn culture (A/B testing new ideas regularly, monitoring results, iterating), you’ll ensure your site keeps improving and stays ahead of both user expectations and competitor offerings.

Performing a CRO audit and the subsequent optimizations can seem daunting, but the payoff is significant. And you don’t have to do it alone. GROW is here to help eCommerce businesses like yours execute these strategies flawlessly. We bring expert eyes, hands-on experience from optimizing sites across US, CA, UK, AU, NZ markets, and a data-driven approach to every change.

If you’re ready to transform your website’s performance, let’s turn these recommendations into reality:

Call to Action: Get Your Free CRO Audit from GROW or Schedule a Consultation Today. Our team will gladly review your site (at no cost) and show you where conversion goldmines lie, just as we’ve outlined. We can work with you to implement high-impact improvements and set up tests to ensure you outperform competitors like Conversion.com and beyond. There’s zero obligation – just an opportunity to see what a fresh, expert perspective can do for your online sales.

Don’t let your website’s hidden flaws continue to silently steal revenue. Take action now to optimize and thrive. Contact GROW for a free CRO audit or a personalized consultation, and let’s start converting more of your visitors into loyal customers today. Your next big boost in sales could be just a few tweaks away – together, we’ll reach it.